Arrow Chart & Selection Guide — Carbon, Aluminum & Wood

Arrow Chart & Selection Guide

Complete guide to choosing the right arrows. Compare carbon, aluminum, and wood arrows for hunting, target, and traditional archery.
Popular models, specifications, and expert recommendations.

🎯 Quick arrow selection

Hunting?Carbon arrows 400-500 grains
Target archery?Aluminum or carbon-aluminum
Traditional bow?Carbon or wood arrows
Don't know your spine?Use spine calculator

Arrow material comparison: Carbon vs Aluminum vs Wood

Feature Carbon Aluminum Carbon-Aluminum Wood
Weight Lightest (6-9 GPI) Medium (8-11 GPI) Medium (8-10 GPI) Heaviest (9-12 GPI)
Speed Fastest Medium Medium-fast Slowest
Durability Very durable (flexes, rarely breaks) Bends permanently, dents easily Very durable Breaks easily, warps
Straightness Tolerance ±.001" to ±.006" ±.001" to ±.003" ±.0005" to ±.001" ±.010" to ±.025"
Weather Resistance Excellent (unaffected) Poor (oxidizes) Excellent Poor (absorbs moisture)
Cost (per dozen) $80-$200 $60-$120 $150-$250 $50-$120
Best For Hunting, 3D, outdoor target Indoor target Olympic competition Traditional archery
Spine Consistency Good (±5 lbs within dozen) Excellent (±2 lbs) Excellent (±1-2 lbs) Variable (±10-15 lbs)

Which arrow material should you choose?

Ready to buy? Shop carbon arrows on Amazon or all arrow types at Optics Planet.

Best arrows for hunting

Hunting arrow requirements

Successful hunting arrows need:

Top hunting arrow models (carbon)

Arrow Model GPI Range Diameter Spine Range Best For Price/Dozen
Easton 4MM Match Grade 9.5-10.3 4mm (.204") 300-500 Whitetail, mule deer, elk $140-180
Easton 5MM FMJ 11.5-12.8 5mm (.246") 340-500 Heavy arrows, elk, dangerous game $160-200
Carbon Express Maxima Red 9.0-10.4 Standard (.300") 250-500 All-around hunting, proven design $120-150
Gold Tip Hunter XT 9.5-10.7 Standard (.246") 300-600 Versatile hunting, good value $110-140
Victory RIP TKO 9.8-11.4 Standard (.204"-.246") 300-500 Deep penetration, tough shafts $130-160
Black Eagle Rampage 9.0-9.7 Standard (.246") 350-500 Budget-friendly, reliable $90-120
Easton Axis (original) 8.3-9.5 4mm (.204") 260-500 Classic micro-diameter hunting $120-150

Hunting arrow recommendations by game

Whitetail / Mule Deer (400-500 grain arrows):

Elk / Black Bear (500-600 grain arrows):

Moose / Brown Bear (600+ grain arrows):

Shop hunting arrows at Centerpoint Archery → | Amazon hunting arrows →

Best arrows for target archery

Target arrow priorities

Target arrows optimize for:

Top target arrow models

Arrow Model Material Straightness Weight Match Best For Price/Dozen
Easton X10 Carbon-Aluminum ±.0005" ±0.5 gr Olympic competition (gold standard) $350-450
Easton A/C/E Carbon-Aluminum ±.001" ±1 gr Olympic recurve, outdoor target $220-280
Easton A/C/C Carbon-Aluminum ±.001" ±1 gr Compound target, versatile $180-240
Easton ACE Aluminum-Carbon ±.001" ±1 gr Indoor target (larger diameter) $200-260
Easton Inspire Carbon ±.003" ±2 gr Budget target, 3D competition $100-130
Easton X7 Eclipse Aluminum ±.001" ±1 gr Indoor target (classic choice) $120-160
Easton XX75 Aluminum ±.002" ±2 gr Budget target, practice $60-90
Carbon Express Nano SST Carbon ±.001" ±1 gr 3D competition $140-180
Victory VAP Elite Carbon ±.001" ±1 gr 3D, outdoor target $150-190

Target arrow recommendations by discipline

Olympic Recurve (70 meter outdoor):

Indoor Target (18-20 meter):

3D Competition:

Compound Target:

Shop target arrows at Optics Planet →

Traditional archery arrows (carbon & wood)

Traditional arrow options

Traditional archers shooting longbows, recurves without sights, or primitive bows can choose:

Carbon arrows for traditional archery

Arrow Model GPI Spine Range Features Price/Dozen
Gold Tip Traditional 8.5-9.8 340-800 Wood-grain finish, 5/16" diameter $100-130
Carbon Express Heritage 8.9-9.5 350-800 Classic wood look, tough carbon $90-120
Easton Aftermath 7.8-8.9 340-700 Traditional diameter, modern performance $100-130
Black Eagle Vintage 9.2-10.1 400-700 Real wood grain, carbon core $110-140

Wood arrow specifications

Wood Type Typical Spine Range Diameter Best For Price/Dozen
Port Orford Cedar 40-75 lbs 11/32" (most common) All-around traditional, most popular $70-100
Douglas Fir 35-65 lbs 11/32" Budget wood arrows, practice $50-70
Sitka Spruce 35-70 lbs 11/32" Historical reproductions $60-90
Chundoo (Bamboo) 45-65 lbs 23/64" (large) Heavy arrows, primitive archery $80-120

Wood arrow spine chart (Port Orford Cedar 11/32")

Draw Weight Arrow Length 28" Arrow Length 30" Spine Rating
35-40 lbs 60-65 lbs spine 55-60 lbs spine Approx. 700 carbon equiv.
40-45 lbs 55-60 lbs spine 50-55 lbs spine Approx. 600 carbon equiv.
45-50 lbs 50-55 lbs spine 45-50 lbs spine Approx. 500 carbon equiv.
50-55 lbs 45-50 lbs spine 40-45 lbs spine Approx. 450 carbon equiv.
55-60 lbs 40-45 lbs spine 40-45 lbs spine Approx. 400 carbon equiv.

Note: Wood arrow spine is measured differently than carbon. The spine number represents the draw weight the arrow is designed for, not deflection measurement. Always buy wood arrows slightly weaker (higher spine lbs) than your draw weight for traditional bows shot off the shelf.

Carbon vs wood for traditional archery

Choose carbon arrows if you want:

Choose wood arrows if you want:

Shop traditional carbon arrows at Centerpoint → | Wood arrows at Optics Planet →

Arrow recommendations by bow type

Compound bow arrows

Hunting compound (50-70 lbs draw):

Target compound (50-70 lbs draw):

Recurve bow arrows

Olympic recurve (35-50 lbs draw):

Barebow recurve (35-50 lbs draw):

Recurve hunting (40-55 lbs draw):

Traditional longbow arrows

Traditional longbow (40-60 lbs draw):

Popular arrow brands & series

Easton (industry leader)

Carbon Express (innovation focus)

Gold Tip (versatile lineup)

Victory Archery (premium carbon)

Black Eagle (micro-diameter specialists)

Complete arrow selection guide

📏 Step 1: Calculate Spine

Use our arrow spine calculator with your draw weight, arrow length, and point weight. Proper spine is critical for accuracy.

📐 Step 2: Determine Length

Use our arrow length calculator. Arrows must be long enough for safety plus clearance past arrow rest at full draw.

⚖️ Step 3: Choose Material

Hunting/3D = carbon. Indoor target = aluminum. Olympic = carbon-aluminum. Traditional = carbon or wood based on preference.

💰 Step 4: Set Budget

Budget: $70-100/dozen. Mid-range: $100-150/dozen. Premium: $150-250/dozen. Don't cheap out on hunting arrows - durability matters.

How many arrows should I buy?

Arrow quality tiers explained

Budget arrows ($70-100/dozen):

Mid-range arrows ($100-150/dozen):

Premium arrows ($150-250/dozen):

Why arrow selection matters more than bow selection

Most archers spend weeks researching which bow to buy, then grab whatever arrows the shop recommends without much further thought. It's common to drop $800 on a bow and $80 on a dozen bargain-bin arrows, then end up frustrated months later when groups won't tighten, broadheads won't fly straight, and arrows keep breaking.

The reality is that arrow selection matters as much — or more — than bow selection for accuracy and consistency. A $1,200 Mathews or Hoyt is only as good as the arrows shot through it. A mediocre bow with excellent arrows will outshoot an excellent bow with mediocre arrows almost every time.

This shows up constantly at 3D shoots: an archer with a $1,500 compound and top-shelf sight and rest is shooting budget arrows with ±.006" straightness tolerance, landing 6-inch groups at 40 yards and blaming their release or sight settings. Meanwhile, someone with a $600 bow and Easton 4MM Match Grade arrows is drilling the 12-ring consistently.

For hunting, arrow quality matters even more. It's not just about tight groups — arrows need to fly identically with broadheads, penetrate deep through bone and muscle, and survive impact with the ground behind the target. A budget dozen that saved $50 can cost a lost deer if an arrow deflects off a rib instead of punching through, or if broadhead plane makes the arrow veer off because the shaft isn't straight.

The good news: the most expensive arrows aren't required to shoot well. Mid-range carbon arrows ($100-150/dozen) are excellent for hunting and most target shooting. Carbon Express Maxima Red, Gold Tip Hunter XT, and Easton Axis are all proven performers used by thousands of successful hunters every year.

Spending more is worth it for serious competition or dangerous-game hunting. For Olympic recurve or serious compound target, arrows like Easton X10 or A/C/E are worth the cost — the consistency difference is measurable and significant. For elk, moose, or bear, premium arrows with tight tolerances help ensure a broadhead flies true when the shot matters most.

One place to save is practice arrows: buy a dozen premium arrows for competition or hunting, then a dozen budget Predators or Warriors in the same spine for practice. Groups won't be quite as tight with the budget arrows, but that's fine for practice — save the good arrows for when it counts.

The bottom line: a flagship bow paired with bargain-bin arrows rarely performs as well as it could. Investing in quality arrows that match a bow's capabilities — correct spine, the right material for the discipline, and appropriate straightness and spine tolerance — tends to improve accuracy and consistency more than any bow upgrade would.

Arrow selection FAQs

What arrows should I buy for hunting?

For hunting: Carbon arrows are best. Recommended models: Easton 4MM or 5MM (340-400 spine), Carbon Express Maxima Red (350-400), Gold Tip Hunter (340-400), Victory RIP TKO (300-400). Target weight: 400-500 grains total for deer, 500-600 grains for elk. Choose spine based on your draw weight and arrow length using our arrow spine calculator. Shop hunting arrows at Centerpoint Archery.

What's the difference between carbon and aluminum arrows?

Carbon arrows: Lighter, faster, more durable, weatherproof, better for hunting. Cost: $80-200/dozen. Aluminum arrows: Heavier, more consistent straightness, better for indoor target, cheaper. Cost: $60-120/dozen. Carbon-aluminum hybrids (A/C/C, A/C/E): Combine both advantages, most expensive ($150-250/dozen), used by Olympic archers. For hunting and outdoor use, choose carbon. For indoor target competition, aluminum or carbon-aluminum.

How do I know what spine arrow I need?

Arrow spine depends on draw weight, arrow length, and point weight. General guide: 30-40 lbs draw = 600-700 spine, 40-50 lbs = 500-600 spine, 50-60 lbs = 400-500 spine, 60-70 lbs = 340-400 spine, 70+ lbs = 300-340 spine. Use our arrow spine calculator for exact recommendations based on your specific bow setup. Lower spine number = stiffer arrow.

What are the best arrows for beginners?

Best beginner arrows: Budget carbon - Carbon Express Predator ($80-100/dozen), Gold Tip Warrior ($70-90/dozen). Mid-range - Easton Inspire ($100-130/dozen), Victory VAP TKO ($110-140/dozen). Buy proper spine for your bow (use spine calculator), get at least 6 arrows to start, and choose durable carbon arrows that can handle beginner mistakes. Avoid cheapest arrows (inconsistent spine, break easily). Shop beginner arrows at Optics Planet.

Should I buy carbon or aluminum arrows for target archery?

For target archery: Indoor target (18-20 meters): Aluminum (Easton X10, ACE, X7) or carbon-aluminum (A/C/C, A/C/E) for tightest groups. Outdoor target (50-90 meters): Carbon-aluminum hybrids (A/C/E, A/C/C) or high-end carbon (Easton X10). 3D archery: Carbon arrows (lighter, faster trajectory). Olympic recurve: Most shoot A/C/E or X10 for competition. Budget target shooting: Easton Inspire or Jazz aluminum.

How much should I spend on arrows?

Budget: $70-100/dozen for practice and casual shooting. Mid-range: $100-150/dozen for hunting and serious target shooting (best value). Premium: $150-250/dozen for competition and serious hunting. For hunting, invest in mid-range or premium - arrow failure costs you game. For practice, budget arrows are fine. Don't cheap out on arrows you'll hunt with.

Can I use hunting arrows for target shooting?

Yes, hunting arrows work fine for target shooting, but they're heavier than optimal for target. Hunting arrows are typically 400-500 grains while target arrows are 350-400 grains. The extra weight causes more drop at distance but doesn't affect accuracy significantly at typical target ranges (20-60 yards). Many archers practice with hunting arrows to ensure their setup is identical for hunting season.

What arrows do Olympic archers use?

Olympic archers predominantly shoot Easton X10 or A/C/E carbon-aluminum arrows. These offer ±.0005" to ±.001" straightness tolerance, ±0.5-1 grain weight matching, and exceptional consistency. Cost: $220-450/dozen. For club-level Olympic recurve, Easton A/C/C or ACE provide excellent performance at lower cost ($180-260/dozen). The precision manufacturing justifies the cost for serious competition.